Blog

Learning Center

We keep you up-to-date with all the latest tax news and changes in the industry.

Italy's Expanding Tax Evasion Sparks Intense Debate: 'Fiscal Terrorism'

Italy's struggle with tax evasion, notorious throughout Europe, has surged to alarming new levels. According to a recent government report analyzed by Reuters, the fiscal shortfall in 2022 soared to €102.5 billion ($119 billion), an increase from the previous year's €99 billion.

Previously marked by slow progress, this reversal started in 2020 and has rapidly intensified. Image 2

Growing Political Controversies

For Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, this new data represents a significant political challenge. Her administration has criticized previous enforcement approaches, which she considered overly harsh, advocating instead for eased restrictions such as raising the cash-payment threshold from €1,000 to €5,000 and introducing tax amnesties for debts dating back to 2023.

Detractors argue these policies incentivize non-compliance. Economists caution that such leniency could unwind a decade of fiscal discipline, jeopardizing the pursuit of transparent and accountable financial practices.

Deputy Economy Minister Maurizio Leo has depicted tax evasion as akin to "terrorism" during a 2024 parliamentary session, amidst increased online surveillance of undeclared earnings.

Revised Methodologies and Their Implications

The updated evasion metrics, provided by the national statistics office ISTAT, reflect a refined data gathering process initiated in 2024. This approach revealed deeper layers of non-compliance than earlier indicated. Between 2018 and 2022, genuine advancements in combating evasion totaled a mere €5.9 billion, not the previously stated €26 billion.

These numbers are not just politically sensitive—they also bear significance in the context of EU fiscal discussions. With Rome under pressure to lower its debt-to-GDP ratio from around 137%, every euro lost to evasion complicates these efforts.

A Broader European Perspective

Italy's "shadow economy" stands out in Europe. As reported by Eurostat, Italians continue a heavy reliance on cash transactions, unlike their European counterparts who have embraced digital payments. In contrast, nations like Spain, France, and Germany have successfully curtailed their informal economic sectors following the pandemic.

Prime Minister Meloni hopes that relaxing punitive measures will enhance tax collection over time. Nevertheless, early results cast doubt on this strategy's effectiveness. Research from the University of Bologna in 2025 suggests voluntary compliance programs recover only about 35–40% of owed taxes. Image 1

Future Directions

Within the proposed 2026 budget, the government includes another tax amnesty, allowing entities to clear debts without facing penalties or interest—a proposal the European Commission regards as "fiscally risky."

This issue transcends politics, rooted instead in long-standing cultural and structural challenges. In regions such as Naples with its cash-oriented tradespeople, or Rome with its frequently under-reported hospitality earnings, tax evasion is an entrenched behavior that reform efforts have struggled to dismantle significantly.

Italy's growing €100-billion tax gap is not only a fiscal indicator but a warning. The nation, once committed to eradicating its shadow economy through modern enforcement techniques, now confronts potential setbacks that could destabilize its financial positioning, investor trust, and EU relations.

Absent potent interventions, the shadow economy potentially endangers the stability of Europe’s fourth-largest economy.

Share this article...

Sign up for our newsletter.

Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

We care about the protection of your data.

Butler Location

12714 W. Hampton Ave, Unit F
Butler, Wisconsin 53007
(414) 509-1626

Milwaukee Location

Remote
Milwaukee, WI 53217